Replaying Game Stories: Finishing the Plot and Understanding the Rules
Replaying game stories can mean revisiting the plot or testing how choices work. A 2020 close reading shows why those goals need separate questions.

Name the question behind another run
Replaying game stories can start with a question about the plot or about how a decision worked. Imagine a fictional mystery in which you identify the thief and reach the credits. You may feel satisfied with the conclusion while still wondering which earlier conversation made the final accusation available.
A second run could investigate that conversation, revisit a favorite scene or try another suspect. Those are different reasons to return. Counting another completed playthrough would not tell an observer which question you were pursuing, or whether the first ending already felt complete.
Read the evidence as close reading
A 2020 paper by Mitchell, Kway and Lee uses repeated close readings of Bandersnatch and Cultist Simulator. Three authors played the works and discussed their experiences. The published accounts center on one author per game. This is interpretive research, without a recruited experimental sample.
A detailed account can connect an interpretation to the encounter that prompted it. When using that account, keep the encounter and the reader visible. A compelling explanation of one journey still needs different evidence before becoming a prediction about another audience.
Separate a settled story from a settled explanation
One Bandersnatch account reaches satisfaction with the story before understanding its choices. The Cultist Simulator account eventually stops after feeling its system is understood, without reaching a victory screen. The paper distinguishes narrative closure from system closure.
For our invented mystery, knowing who stole the jewel settles a plot question. Explaining why a dialogue option appeared settles a rules question. You might care about either, both or neither on another evening. Even an accurate explanation would not oblige you to revisit every available outcome.
Test an interpretation with a concrete alternative
Suppose the mystery offers an accusation only after you inspect a receipt and speak to a witness. On a repeat visit, you skip the receipt and the option disappears. That observation could support a hypothesis that inspecting the receipt matters. It would not yet show whether speaking to the witness is also required.
In a proposed comparison, note the actions taken and the options shown. Change one earlier action and check what follows. These fictional runs illustrate how to investigate a rule. They do not establish how either game in the paper works, or prove that testing rules is more enjoyable than following the story.
Keep different readings in view
Endnotes describe different responses from the other authors. These accounts therefore do not establish a shared player sequence or a reliable prediction of who will replay.
Confidence also deserves its own question in our mystery exercise. A person might believe the receipt alone unlocks the accusation and decide they understand enough. Their decision to stop would record satisfaction with that explanation. Checking whether the explanation matches the actual rule would require another observation.
Choose a useful purpose for returning
Before revisiting an interactive story, name something you want to discover or experience again. It could be one character’s perspective, a choice you remain curious about or a familiar scene whose meaning changed after the ending. That purpose can guide a small return without requiring another complete campaign.
For an original interview exercise, ask what someone expected to learn from replaying and what made them stop. Preserve an answer about a satisfying ending alongside an unanswered rules question. It gives a more specific account of that return than assuming another run means the story was unfinished.
Keep exploring
Sources & further reading
- Mitchell, Kway and Lee (2020): full close-reading study ↗
- DiGRA: publication record for the same paper ↗
Have a correction? Tell our editorial team.