New Game Plus vs Mission Replay: Choose Your Return

Start with how much of the adventure you want back

Choosing New Game Plus vs mission replay starts with the part of a game you want to revisit. In the examples below, New Game Plus restarts a campaign with specified carryover, while mission replay offers a return to selected content. The mode names point to different scales of commitment.

God of War Ragnarök and Marvel's Spider-Man 2 provide established PlayStation examples, checked on October 22, 2026. Their relevant announcements date to 2023 and 2024. We are comparing documented structures, with an additional current support rule, rather than reporting a new launch or our own completed playthrough.

Ragnarök keeps an arsenal while rebuilding the journey

Santa Monica Studio's April 5, 2023 announcement makes Ragnarök's NG+ available after beating the game. Equipment, weapons and skills carry from the previous save, including the Draupnir Spear. The mode also introduces additional progression and an increased level cap. Its console versions are PS4 and PS5.

There are specific story restrictions: Sonic and Hex arrows are unavailable at the start, and areas requiring those arrows or the spear stay locked until the relevant quest point. Possessing a weapon and having permission to pass every associated obstacle are therefore separate conditions. A returning arsenal changes your starting tools without turning the world into a completed-map shortcut.

Spider-Man 2 names both routes back

Insomniac's post updated March 7, 2024 confirms that Spider-Man 2 version 1.002 shipped with New Game+ and Mission Replay on PS5. The developer describes carrying suits and abilities into another playthrough, alongside further unlocks such as Ultimate Levels. It separately offers replaying a favorite mission or two.

That distinction helps when the attraction is one encounter rather than another trip through the campaign. Selective repetition can match the narrower goal; NG+ can support exploring how familiar tools change a longer sequence. The announcement does not establish one universal reward, equipment or difficulty rule for every game's replay menu, so keep those questions attached to the named title.

A completed character is not a completed story file

Insomniac's support answer, updated November 21, 2025, gives a useful example of a completion-dependent setting. Spider-Man 2's time-of-day control requires finishing the main story in the current file. Starting NG+ makes it unavailable until that new file's story is completed, even if the earlier playthrough already qualified.

For planning, separate three columns: retained character tools, renewed story progress and settings unlocked by completion. A yes in the first column does not fill the other two. This explains why a returning player can have familiar abilities while still encountering restrictions associated with the new campaign's position. It also makes a missing setting a more precise support question.

Try a two-session planning exercise

Imagine two evenings with different aims. On the first, you want to revisit one favorite encounter and compare two approaches. On the second, you want to experience the whole story with an equipment combination learned late in the original run. These are hypothetical plans, not estimates of either game's completion time.

For the focused evening, inspect the supported mission-replay option and its conditions. For the campaign evening, inspect the NG+ carryover list and the gates that remain. If comparing combat approaches, keep difficulty and equipment choices visible in your notes. A better result under different conditions cannot isolate which change helped. No second playthrough is required simply because its menu option exists.

Choose a return that has a useful stopping point

Define the ending of the session before entering a replay: perhaps understanding one encounter, trying a build through an opening section or revisiting a particular story moment. That makes a small return worthwhile on its own, instead of turning every completed game into another full-campaign obligation.

Read the selected mode's description for your installed version and intended save. Look for what it retains, what it restarts and which prerequisites still apply. The strongest comparison is between those actual rules and the experience you want next. A mode label can guide the search; the game's specific implementation determines the journey.

Keep exploring

FOLLOW THE SOURCE

Sources & further reading

Have a correction? Tell our editorial team.

✦ NICE. YOU LEARNED SOMETHING.